Is Enameled Cast Iron Cookware Worth the Investment?

Cast iron has long been a staple in kitchens for its unparalleled heat retention and natural non-stick surface. But traditional cast iron requires careful seasoning and maintenance. Enter enameled cast iron, which combines cast iron’s superb cooking performance with an easy-to-clean enameled surface that allows it to be used for virtually any cooking task.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know about enameled cast iron cookware including its pros and cons, top brands, care and cleaning recommendations, how it compares to traditional cast iron, and the very best recipes to cook in your enameled cast iron pots and pans.

What Exactly Is Enameled Cast Iron?

Enameled cast iron fuses cast iron’s excellent heat conduction and retention with a glossy and non-reactive enamel coating applied to the surface. The enamel creates a durable, non-stick barrier that allows you to cook acidic foods like tomatoes without the seasoning breaking down over time like it would with regular cast iron.

The base is still cast iron to take advantage of its unmatched searing, heat distribution, and oven-to-table versatility. The interior enamel coating is applied in a kiln at extremely high temperatures to bind it to the iron permanently. This makes enameled cast iron superior for cooking French classics like beef bourguignon that require slow braising with wine.

Popular brands producing high-quality enameled cast iron include Le Creuset, Staub, Lodge, and Cuisinart. And it comes in just about every shape and size from petite ramekins to roasting pans and extra-large Dutch ovens perfect for preparing family dinners.

Key Benefits and Drawbacks of Enameled Cast Iron

Pros:
  • Non-stick cooking surface that’s also non-reactive and won’t leach iron into food
  • Ideal for acidic ingredients like tomatoes, vinegar, and wine since the enamel prevents reactions
  • Lower maintenance than seasoned bare cast iron
  • Range of vivid colors from fiery flame orange to a cool Caribbean blue
  • Superior heat distribution and retention like traditional cast iron
Cons:
  • Heavy and expensive compared to other cookware types
  • Prone to chipping if dropped or banged around
  • Hand wash only since the enamel can dull in a dishwasher

For most home cooks, the advantages outweigh the downsides. Let’s look closer at the best uses for enameled cast iron to help you determine if it’s worth the investment.

The Many Uses for Enameled Cast Iron Cookware

Thanks to its versatile cooking surface, enameled cast iron works for almost any stovetop or oven cooking technique. Here are some of the top ways to put enameled cast iron to work in your kitchen:

  • Braising and stewing: The Dutch oven shape is ideal for braising beef, chicken, or pork and slow simmering flavorful stews. The enameled surface won’t react with acidic braising liquid.
  • Baking: From macaroni and cheese to baked ziti to golden cornbread, enameled cast iron creates crispy edges and perfectly baked dishes.
  • Roasting: Roasted vegetables or a savory pork roast come out caramelized and tender when roasted in an enameled cast iron pan.
  • Frying: The excellent heat retention allows you to fry foods like chicken breasts to a juicy, golden finish. Avoid super acidic foods when frying which can deteriorate the enamel over time.
  • Bread: Nothing beats baking crusty artisan bread in a covered enameled cast iron pot. The steam creates that crackly crisp crust.

So as you can see, enameled cast iron works for almost any cooking task thanks to its versatility. Now let’s go over proper care.

Caring for Enameled Cast Iron to Make it Last

While enameled cast iron doesn’t require quite as much fussy care as traditional cast iron, there are still a few habits to keep in mind:

  • Hand wash only: Skip the dishwasher which can create micro-abrasions in the enamel over time.
  • Avoid metal utensils: Use wood or silicone utensils to prevent scratching and chips in the enamel.
  • Don’t preheat empty: Avoid preheating an empty piece as the enamel can crack or warp under sudden high heat.
  • Prevent thermal shock: Don’t go from stovetop to cold water or vice versa, allow to cool first to prevent cracking.
  • Remove food debris: Don’t allow stuck-on food bits to carbonize, clean after each use.
  • Re-season: After cleaning, apply a light layer of oil to maintain the cooking surface over time. You can learn more about seasoning enameled cast iron properly in this guide from The Kitchen Feast.

Treat it with care and your enameled cast iron could last for decades!

Leading Enameled Cast Iron Brands

Not all enameled cast iron is created equal. Here are some of the top brands producing high-quality enameled cast iron cookware:

  • Le Creuset: The French brand is arguably the gold standard for premium enameled cast iron, available in a rainbow of bright colors.
  • Staub: Another French brand renowned for its quality and signature matte black interior enamel. Great for browning.
  • Lodge: Known for its bare cast iron, Lodge also produces more budget-friendly enameled cast iron in smaller sizes.
  • Cuisinart: A very affordable enameled cast iron line that comes in fun bright hues. Good value for the price.

While pricier, Le Creuset and Staub pay for themselves over time thanks to their outstanding craftsmanship and materials.

Delicious Recipes to Make in Enameled Cast Iron

Here are just some of the many meals perfectly suited for enameled cast iron:

  • Beef Bourguignon: The Dutch oven shape and braising capabilities are ideal for this French beef stew.
  • Chicken Pot Pie: Make the filling in the enameled cast iron pan, then top with fluffy biscuits for a comforting pot pie.
  • Lasagna: From oven-to-table, bake and serve lasagna directly in an enameled cast iron baking dish.
  • Deep Dish Pizza: Create homemade deep dish in an enameled cast iron skillet for a restaurant-quality pie.
  • Pork Roast: Roasting a pork loin or shoulder results in tender, succulent meat when cooked in enameled cast iron.

The options are endless! Enameled cast iron works for baking, braising, frying, roasting, and more.

How Does Enameled Cast Iron Compare to Traditional Cast Iron?

Enameled cast iron provides many benefits over traditional bare cast iron:

  • The enamel coating creates a non-stick surface so food releases easily without sticking. Bare cast iron relies on seasoning for non-stick.
  • Enameled cast iron is non-reactive for cooking acidic ingredients while bare iron can react with acids.
  • Bare cast iron must be seasoned while the enamel means less seasoning required.
  • Enameled iron is generally dishwasher safe while bare iron must always be hand washed.

However, bare cast iron heats up faster and can reach higher temperatures. It also costs significantly less than quality enameled cast iron.

So if you enjoy the ritual of seasoning bare cast iron, it provides an affordable option. But for most cooks, easy-cleaning enameled cast iron is worthwhile for its versatility.

Should You Buy Enameled Cast Iron Cookware?

In summary, enameled cast iron like Le Creuset is an excellent investment for any home chef. While not cheap, its superior heat distribution and retention coupled with a durable enamel surface allow it to excel at nearly any cooking task imaginable from searing chicken breasts to baking cobblers.

The enamel coating is easy to clean and maintain. And with proper care, enameled cast iron pots and pans should last decades. With its versatility, performance, and timeless beauty, enameled cast iron truly earns its reputation as high-quality heirloom cookware.

So if you’re looking for cookware that can be passed down for generations, enameled cast iron is one of your best options. Both Staub and Le Creuset come with extensive warranties, a testament to how long they can last. While the price tag is steep, when you consider how long it endures and how often you’ll use it, enameled cast iron is worth every penny.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *