Are Natural Gas and Propane Interchangeable? Everything You Need to Know

natural-gas-or-propane

Natural gas and propane are two popular fuel sources used for heating, cooking, and powering appliances in homes and businesses. Though they share some similarities, there are important differences between them that determine whether or not they can be used interchangeably.

An Overview of Natural Gas and Propane

Natural gas is a fossil fuel comprised mostly of methane. It is extracted from underground deposits and distributed through pipelines to homes and businesses. Appliances that use natural gas must be designed for that specific fuel.

Propane is a liquid fuel stored in pressurized tanks. It is produced as a by-product of natural gas processing and petroleum refining. Propane is used for applications where natural gas service is unavailable, like rural homes, portable grills, and RV appliances.

Both natural gas and propane burn cleanly and are considered more environmentally friendly than fuels like gasoline, diesel, and heating oil. However, there are some distinct attributes that set them apart:

Natural Gas

  • Transported through pipelines
  • Measured in cubic feet (CF)
  • Requires specialized appliances
  • Service provided by utility companies
  • Energy rating is measured in British Thermal Units (BTUs) per cubic foot

Propane

  • Compressed into portable pressurized tanks
  • Measured in gallons (or pounds)
  • Used for mobile applications
  • Provided by private distributors
  • Energy rating is measured in BTUs per gallon

The Interchangeability of Natural Gas and Propane

So can natural gas and propane be used interchangeably? The short answer is no. The two fuels require different equipment suited specifically for one fuel or the other. However, propane can be substituted for natural gas in some circumstances.

Heating Systems

Most furnaces and boilers are designed exclusively for either natural gas or propane. Exceptions include combination heating systems engineered to run on both fuels. Even then, the appliance must be manually switched from one fuel source to the other. It requires adjustments to the air-to-fuel ratio settings. Dual-fuel systems allow homes to maintain heat if their main energy supply is disrupted.

Trying to burn propane in a natural gas furnace or vice versa without proper equipment and adjustments can be inefficient or even dangerous. An improperly configured fuel-air mixture can produce carbon monoxide or result in detonation.

Cooking Appliances

Like heating equipment, most stoves, ovens, and cooktops are typically set up for either natural gas or propane—but not both simultaneously. Some high-end residential ranges offer dual-fuel configurations, enabling the cooktop burners and oven to run on natural gas while allowing the grill or other components to connect to an external propane tank. This gives owners the benefit of professional-style outdoor cooking capabilities.

Again, safely switching between the two fuels on a single appliance requires technical calibrations. Attempting to swap fuels without reconfiguring the unit could severely damage the equipment or lead to a fire hazard.

Standby Generators

Emergency standby generators provide backup electricity when the main power goes out. Natural gas generators use utility service lines to fuel the engine. Meanwhile, propane generators have an integrated propane tank that must be filled periodically.

Generator equipment is manufactured specifically for the type of fuel they utilize. The only exception would be bi-fuel generators with separate natural gas and propane carburetions. Qualified technicians must properly enable each system and recalibrate the engine when transitioning between them.

Fireplaces

Indoor gas fireplaces offer the ambiance of real fire without the mess and labor of wood. As is common with other gas appliances, they are designed for either natural gas or propane. Trying to burn the wrong fuel can be extremely hazardous.

Outdoor gas fireplaces like patio heaters are almost exclusively propane-fueled since they aren’t connected to utility lines.

Gas Grills

The vast majority of outdoor gas grills are engineered for liquid propane placed in small tanks inside the unit. However, some natural gas grills are configured to hook up to home gas lines. They typically cost more but avoid the need to refill propane tanks. Converting between fuel sources would require completely replacing key grill components.

Vehicles/Engines

Vehicles fueled by compressed natural gas (CNG) or liquid propane autogas require unique engine configurations and fuel systems. Though both burn cleaner than gasoline or diesel, the fuels cannot be interchanged without extensively modifying the vehicle.

Propane as a Natural Gas Substitute

While appliances cannot seamlessly switch between natural gas and propane, propane can be used as a replacement in some instances.

If a home or business loses access to natural gas service, it is possible to install propane-fueled equipment for heating, cooking, etc. This requires purchasing new approved appliances designed specifically for propane fuel. A qualified technician must remove the natural gas equipment and install propane system components like tanks, regulators, and piping.

In fact, over 6 million U.S. homes in outlying areas use propane as their primary energy source where natural gas is unavailable. While more expensive than utility gas, propane allows rural properties to enjoy modern conveniences.

The conversion process also applies to portable equipment like construction heaters and fork lifts that normally use natural gas. Special propane-powered models can be purchased as an alternate fuel source.

4 myths and facts related to the article “Are Natural Gas and Propane Interchangeable?”:

Myth 1: Propane and natural gas are the same thing.

Fact: While propane and natural gas are both fossil fuels, they have very different properties. Propane is a liquid that is highly pressurized and stored in tanks, while natural gas is a gas that is distributed through underground pipelines. Their different states and delivery methods mean they cannot be used interchangeably without converting equipment.

Myth 2: Appliances can easily switch between propane and natural gas.

Fact: Most appliances are designed specifically for either propane or natural gas. A few high-end appliance models may allow dual-fuel capabilities, but they require manual calibration adjustments to safely switch between the fuels. You cannot simply connect a device designed for one fuel to the other.

Myth 3: If natural gas service is disrupted, you can use propane instead.

Fact: While propane can serve as a natural gas substitute, it requires professional installation of approved, propane-fueled appliances. Technicians must remove any natural gas equipment and properly configure components like tanks, lines, and regulators to operate on propane.

Myth 4: Propane and natural gas are interchangeable in vehicles.

Fact: Vehicles powered by compressed natural gas (CNG) or propane autogas require unique engine configurations and fuel systems designed specifically for those fuels. You cannot simply switch between CNG and propane in a standard vehicle without mechanical modifications.

The key takeaway is that propane and natural gas are not directly interchangeable. Safely switching fuels requires converting equipment using proper technical procedures. Assumptions that the two fuels are identical or easily swappable can lead to disastrous results.

Key Takeaways: Can Natural Gas and Propane Be Used Interchangeably?

  • Natural gas and propane have unique properties requiring specialized equipment.
  • Appliances and equipment cannot directly interchange between natural gas and propane without modifications.
  • Propane can serve as a substitute for natural gas where utility lines are inaccessible.
  • Converting appliances from natural gas to propane requires professional installation of approved equipment.
  • Attempting to burn the wrong fuel type without proper conversion can severely damage equipment and create safety hazards.

The Bottom Line

Due to critical differences in their physical makeup, natural gas and propane are not inherently interchangeable. The only way to safely switch fuels in an appliance is to completely replace key components with equipment engineered specifically for that fuel. While propane can step in as a natural gas alternative in some remote residential and commercial applications, the two cannot be swapped directly without extensive modifications to properly calibrate the fuel-to-air ratio. Always consult qualified technicians when converting equipment to a different fuel source.

Further Reading: Explore These Related Topics

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *